Phone icon Europe: +44 (20) 81784200
APAC: +61 (07) 2146 2211
North America: +1 (877) 7030866
October 27, 2025

The Manager Effect: Why Who You Work For Matters More Than Where You Work

Alexis Bulanadi

The Manager Effect: Why Who You Work For Matters More Than Where You Work

When employees quit, leaders often look at pay, workload, or flexibility as the reason. But new research points to something simpler and far more powerful: the manager.

A large-scale study of more than 200,000 employees found that the best managers don’t just motivate or monitor. They match people to the right roles, unlocking performance and retention gains that last long after the manager has moved on.

At Filta, we’ve seen the same pattern across global teams. In our own analysis, employees who have strong relationships with their managers are more likely to stay with the company long-term. The connection between manager and employee is not just cultural, it’s strategic.

When managers focus on fit and connection, not control, companies grow stronger from the inside out.

What Great Managers Actually Do

The research found that “high-flyer” managers, often promoted early for their leadership potential, have an outsized impact on both people and profits.

  • Employees under these managers earn 13 percent more after seven years.
  • Productivity gains persist even after the manager leaves.
  • Every dollar invested in these managers returns five dollars in higher output.

These outcomes don’t come from charisma or authority. They come from strategic placement, genuine care, and mentoring. High-impact managers know how to spot potential, realign roles, and guide growth before disengagement sets in. They don’t just manage work. They engineer growth.

What Leaders Can Learn

The data is clear, but results only come when leaders turn insight into action. Here’s how to make management your company’s most powerful retention strategy.

1. Make talent matching a core management skill.
Most managers are trained to deliver results, not to design teams. But that has to evolve. Equip managers with tools for understanding strengths, like skill mapping, personality insights, or 360 feedback. Encourage them to ask their people, “What gives you energy?” and “Where do you want to grow?” When employees feel seen and matched to the right work, motivation follows.

2. Keep career paths open and flexible.
Rigid hierarchies create frustration. Build an internal “opportunity marketplace” where employees can apply for cross-functional projects or short-term rotations. Managers who recommend team members for new experiences show trust, and that trust builds loyalty.

3. Rotate your managers to spread leadership quality.
Move your best managers across functions or teams every 18 to 24 months. This spreads great leadership practices and develops empathy, helping managers better understand the people they lead.

4. Redefine what success means for managers.
Go beyond deliverables. Measure how many people under a manager get promoted, reskilled, or retained. Reward leaders who consistently help their teams grow. When career development becomes part of a manager’s success metric, engagement rises across the board.

5. Build a mentoring culture that fits your structure.
You don’t need complex programs. What matters is consistency. Encourage managers to hold short but meaningful one-on-one conversations – even five minutes of real check-in each week can build trust. Ask what’s working, what’s not, and how the company can support their growth.

6. Lead with real connection, not just communication.
People can sense the difference between a manager who checks in and a manager who truly cares. Encourage leaders to understand their team members’ motivations, challenges, and wins beyond the daily tasks. Recognizing small efforts or asking about personal milestones can transform how employees see their workplace. In distributed teams, especially across the Philippines and Colombia, this kind of genuine connection bridges distance and builds belonging.

How Filta Helps

At Filta, we help global companies build people-first teams in the Philippines and Colombia. We’ve learned that the single biggest factor influencing retention isn’t just simply perks or pay, but it’s also the relationship between managers and their people.

That’s why we partner with businesses to:

  • Support managers to match people to the right roles and development paths.
  • Help flexible global team structures that promote growth and connection.
  • Guide managers with leadership programs focused on empathy, mentorship, and accountability.

We believe that the most powerful investment you can make in your business is not just in hiring talent, but it’s also in how your leaders manage and care for them.

If you want to learn how to better manage your global teams, improve productivity, and strengthen retention with the right leadership approach,  book a free consultation at filtaglobal.com and let’s chat.

To explore more resources, the latest insights, and on-the-ground updates about building and managing global remote teams, visit filtaglobal.com.

Share on:

Read more insights and trends to power
your hiring decisions.

FiltaGlobal | The best place to hire awesome people from anywhere in the world, with seamless payroll, HR, and compliance solutions.